PATH ALikely
If opposition stays limited to the five incoming senators...
...Schumer is re-elected leader comfortably.
Senate Democrats pick their majority leader
Senate Democrats elect their leader for the new majority in a closed-door, secret-ballot vote expected in early December. Chuck Schumer needs a simple majority of the caucus, projected at 54 to 56 senators.
What's at stake: Five incoming senators have said publicly they won't back Schumer. No returning senator has said so publicly.
Next: Senate Democrats caucus vote
Date TBD
Our position:Against
Against keeping Chuck Schumer as Senate Democratic leader
Senate Democrats should pick a new leader for the new majority.
Schumer spent the 2026 primaries backing establishment picks over the candidates voters chose. He recruited Gov. Janet Mills in Maine, and she left the race before the primary. He steered donors to Rep. Haley Stevens in Michigan and Rep. Angie Craig in Minnesota. Both lost their primaries, to Abdul El-Sayed and Peggy Flanagan. Stevens then endorsed the Republican. Some of his own Senate colleagues questioned that strategy publicly.
When Democrats last held the Senate, abortion rights were never written into law. In May 2022, with a 50-50 Senate and the Supreme Court about to overturn Roe v. Wade, the Women’s Health Protection Act failed 49 to 51, with every Republican and Sen. Joe Manchin voting no, and far short of the 60 votes the filibuster requires. Democrats did not change the filibuster rules to pass it. Roe fell weeks later with no federal protection in place.
On Israel, he has not moved with his party. In a February 2026 Gallup poll, 65 percent of Democrats said they sympathize more with Palestinians, against 17 percent with Israelis. In April 2026, 40 Senate Democrats voted to block a sale of military bulldozers to Israel and 36 voted to block a bomb sale. Schumer voted against both, as he did in July 2025, when he said security assistance to Israel "is not about any one government but about our support for the Israeli people."
His leadership has also cost the party trust with its own voters. In March 2025 he supplied the votes to pass a Republican funding bill that most Democrats opposed, and Indivisible called on him to step aside. In a June 2026 Politico poll, 47 percent of likely Democratic voters said he should not remain leader, against 28 percent who said he should. Five of the incoming Democratic senators have said they will not back him.
The new majority needs a leader the new class trusts.
Sources (9)
- The Maine Monitor: Mills exit has Democrats asking what Schumer was thinking
- MS NOW: Stevens, Schumer pick in Michigan, endorsed the Republican after losing
- The Hill: Senate Democrats question Schumer strategy after Maine
- NBC News: abortion rights bill fails 49 to 51 (May 11, 2022)
- AP via KSAT: Gallup, February 2026, Democrats 65 to 17 percent
- AP via WTOP: most Senate Democrats vote to block arms sales to Israel (April 2026)
- AP via WCAX: Schumer votes against, statement on security assistance (July 2025)
- Indivisible: call for Schumer to step aside (March 15, 2025)
- Newsweek: Democrats rallying against Schumer, citing June 2026 Politico poll
Take action
Find your representatives. We will show you how to reach them, with a message to start from.
Or pick your state and district
Key dates
- Date TBDNext
Senate Democrats caucus vote
Private, secret ballot. Expected in early December.
If / then
Will Chuck Schumer be re-elected Senate Democratic leader?
PATH BUnlikely
If returning senators start joining the opposition...
...a challenger becomes viable and the secret ballot turns competitive.
Where they stand
Vote math
If every senator in the Democratic caucus without a clear no votes for Chuck Schumer, that is 49 votes. That clears the 28 needed.
- Said yes: 2
- Nothing public, assumed yes: 46
- Undecided / conditions: 1
- Clear no: 5
The undecided can shift it. If all 1 undecided members voted no along with the clear no votes, Chuck Schumer would have 48, which still clears 28.
For the no votes to matter, they have to push Chuck Schumer below the line. That takes 27 senators in the Democratic caucus voting for someone else (22 more than the 5 with a clear no today).
| Watch | Official | Position | What they said | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charles E. Schumer Letter (soon) | For | Said "I'll be re-elected as majority leader." | foxnews.com Nov 4, 2026 | |
| Sheldon Whitehouse Letter (soon) | For | Said in a statement: “Schumer delivering a Democratic Senate certainly justifies another term as leader.” | spokesman.com Nov 6, 2026 | |
| Elissa Slotkin Letter (soon) | Undecided / conditions | Said in June: “I believe we need significant new leadership. The old models are no longer working.” In October she said “we have to see what the results of the election are.” She has not said how she will vote on Schumer. pbs.org | newsweek.com | |
| Juliana Stratton Incoming Contact info coming | Against | Has said she won't back Schumer for leader. | yahoo.com Nov 4, 2026 | |
| Adam Hamilton Incoming Contact info coming | Against | Has said he won't vote for Schumer as leader. | yahoo.com Nov 4, 2026 | |
| Troy Jackson Incoming Contact info coming | Against | Has said he won't vote for Schumer as leader. | yahoo.com Nov 4, 2026 | |
| Abdul El-Sayed Incoming Contact info coming | Against | Has called Sen. Chris Van Hollen his "number one pick for majority leader." | thehill.com Nov 4, 2026 | |
| Peggy Flanagan Incoming Contact info coming | Against | Has said she won't back Schumer for leader. | yahoo.com Nov 4, 2026 | |
| Mark Kelly Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Ruben Gallego Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Adam B. Schiff Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Alex Padilla Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| John W. Hickenlooper Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Michael F. Bennet Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Christopher Murphy Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Richard Blumenthal Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Christopher A. Coons Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Lisa Blunt Rochester Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Jon Ossoff Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Raphael G. Warnock Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Brian Schatz Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Mazie K. Hirono Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Josh Turek Incoming Contact info coming | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Tammy Duckworth Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Edward J. Markey Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Elizabeth Warren Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Angela D. Alsobrooks Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Chris Van Hollen Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Angus S. King, Jr. Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Amy Klobuchar Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Roy Cooper Incoming Contact info coming | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Chris Pappas Incoming Contact info coming | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Margaret Wood Hassan Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Andy Kim Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Cory A. Booker Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Ben Ray Luján Letter (soon) | Nothing public | Asked about changing Senate Democratic leadership, did not say whether he backs Schumer. Said: “I look forward to new leaders like Brian Schatz serving in leadership.” | abqjournal.com Oct 2, 2026 | |
| Martin Heinrich Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Catherine Cortez Masto Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Jacky Rosen Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Kirsten E. Gillibrand Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Sherrod Brown Incoming Contact info coming | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Jeff Merkley Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Ron Wyden Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| John Fetterman Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Jack Reed Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Annie Andrews Incoming Contact info coming | Nothing public | — | — | |
| James Talarico Incoming Contact info coming | Nothing public | Has not said whether he would support Schumer. | foxnews.com Nov 4, 2026 | |
| Mark R. Warner Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Tim Kaine Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Bernard Sanders Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Peter Welch Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Maria Cantwell Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Patty Murray Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — | |
| Tammy Baldwin Letter (soon) | Nothing public | — | — |
Know where someone stands on this? Send us one you found, or ask us to look into it.